What Happens When Lifting Equipment Fails A LOLER Thorough Examination?
A failed LOLER inspection means the competent person has found a defect in the lifting equipment that is, or could become, a danger to people, and has written it into the report of thorough examination. What happens next depends on which kind of defect it is. If it is a danger now, the equipment must not be used until it has been put right. If it could become a danger later, the report gives a time by which that could happen, and the equipment may be used until then but not after, unless the defect has been remedied. The examiner must tell the employer about the defect forthwith, and where there is an existing or imminent risk of serious personal injury, a copy of the report also goes to the enforcing authority.
If lifting equipment has failed and been repaired, or its next thorough examination is coming up, send the equipment list and site address to info@gsbinspections.co.uk and we aim to come back with a quote within 48 hours.
There Is No Pass Mark In A LOLER Thorough Examination
LOLER does not use the words pass or fail. Regulation 9 of the Lifting Operations and Lifting Equipment Regulations 1998 requires lifting equipment to be thoroughly examined for defects, and Schedule 1 sets out what the report of that examination must contain. Two of those particulars decide what people mean by a pass: a statement, where it is the case, that the equipment would be safe to operate, and the identification of any part with a defect that is or could become a danger to persons, with a description of the defect.
A fail, in everyday terms, is a report that records a dangerous defect, or one that does not state the equipment is safe to operate. The rest of this guide follows that report from the moment it lands.
Dangerous Now Or Dangerous By A Date: The Two Kinds Of LOLER Defect
Schedule 1 asks the examiner for different information depending on how serious the defect is.
- A defect that is a danger now. The report identifies the part, describes the defect and gives particulars of the repair, renewal or alteration needed to remedy it. Regulation 10(3) then requires the employer to make sure the equipment is not used until the defect is rectified.
- A defect that could become a danger. The report gives the time by which it could become dangerous and the work needed to remedy it. HSE’s guidance says a defect like this does not require use to stop immediately, but it must be fixed, or the equipment taken out of use, within the time stated on the report.
The second kind needs a diary entry. The date may sit months away on the second page of a report, and the duty to stop using the equipment when it passes rests with the employer, not with the examiner. Put it wherever your renewal dates already live.
Who Is Told About A LOLER Defect, And When
Regulation 10(1) puts the reporting duties on the person who makes the thorough examination:
- the employer must be notified forthwith of any defect that is or could become a danger to persons;
- a written report containing the Schedule 1 particulars goes to the employer, and to anyone from whom the equipment was hired or leased;
- where the defect involves an existing or imminent risk of serious personal injury, a copy of the report goes to the relevant enforcing authority.
Under Regulation 10(4) the enforcing authority is HSE where the employer has hired or leased the equipment, and otherwise the authority that enforces health and safety law at the premises where the examination took place. HSE’s guidance on thorough examination of lifting equipment says the authority may follow up such reports to check that the risk is being adequately managed. The copy is a legal duty on the examiner, not a complaint about you; if the authority does follow up, the question is whether the equipment came out of use and the defect was dealt with.
Taking Lifting Equipment Out Of Use After A Failed Inspection
HSE’s guidance says that once you are told of a dangerous defect you must take effective action to manage the risk, which means the equipment is not used until the defect is fixed. In practice that usually involves:
- isolating the equipment, or moving it out of the working area, so it cannot be used by mistake;
- labelling it clearly as out of use, with the reason;
- telling every shift and team that uses it, including agency and contractor staff;
- quarantining failed slings, chains, shackles and other lifting accessories away from serviceable stock, or destroying them;
- arranging a safe alternative for the lifts the equipment normally does, so nobody is tempted to work round it.
A defect dealt with during the visit still goes on the record. HSE’s guidance says such defects must be confirmed in writing in the report even if they are remedied immediately, and gives a sling being destroyed as the example.
Repairing The Defect Is A Separate Job From The LOLER Examination
The report says what repair, renewal or alteration is needed. It does not carry it out. Lifting equipment is also work equipment, and Regulation 5 of the Provision and Use of Work Equipment Regulations 1998 (PUWER) requires every employer to make sure work equipment is maintained in an efficient state, in efficient working order and in good repair. The repair is that maintenance duty in action, done by whoever maintains the equipment: the manufacturer, a service company, a hire firm or your own maintenance team.
Keep a note of what was done, by whom and when, against the identification given on the report. PUWER also requires any machinery maintenance log to be kept up to date, and a repair record answers the first question anyone reading a report with a defect on it will ask.
Does Lifting Equipment Need A New LOLER Examination After Repair?
LOLER does not name repair as a trigger in its own words. Regulation 9 requires a thorough examination before first use, after installation or assembly at a new site where safety depends on it, at the periodic intervals, and each time exceptional circumstances liable to jeopardise the safety of the equipment have occurred.
Whether a repair calls for a fresh thorough examination is therefore a judgement about the equipment and the work done. In our view, where a load-bearing component has been replaced, such as a chain, wire rope, hook or structural member, it makes sense to ask a competent person whether the equipment should be examined again before it goes back into use, rather than waiting for the next periodic date.
Hired Lifting Equipment That Fails A LOLER Inspection
Where the equipment is hired or leased, Regulation 10 requires the report to go to the person it was hired or leased from as well as to you, and any copy for the enforcing authority goes to HSE. The duty to stop using the equipment still sits with the employer using it. Tell the hire company straight away so it can repair or replace the item; the hire agreement will normally say who pays.
RIDDOR And A LOLER Defect
Finding a defect during a thorough examination is not, by itself, one of the dangerous occurrences HSE lists under the Reporting of Injuries, Diseases and Dangerous Occurrences Regulations (RIDDOR). HSE’s dangerous occurrences guidance covers the collapse or overturning of lifting equipment, or the failure of any load-bearing part, meaning a component that breaks down mechanically during normal operation.
If the defect came to light because something failed in use, RIDDOR is a separate question from the report of thorough examination, answered by what happened rather than by what the examiner found afterwards. An event like that is also likely to be exceptional circumstances under Regulation 9, so the equipment needs a thorough examination before it is used again.
Failed LOLER Inspection Questions
Can we use lifting equipment that has failed its LOLER inspection?
Not if the report records a defect that is a danger now: Regulation 10(3) requires the employer to make sure it is not used until the defect is rectified. If the defect could become a danger by a stated time, the equipment may be used until that time, but not after it unless the defect has been put right.
Will the examiner send our LOLER report to HSE?
Only where the defect involves an existing or imminent risk of serious personal injury. The examiner must then send a copy of the report to the enforcing authority: HSE for hired or leased equipment, otherwise the authority for the premises. HSE’s guidance says the authority may follow up to check the risk is being managed.
Who repairs lifting equipment after a failed examination?
The employer arranges it, through whoever maintains the equipment. Keeping work equipment in good repair is a duty under Regulation 5 of PUWER. The report of thorough examination says what repair, renewal or alteration is needed, not who should carry it out.
Is a dangerous defect reportable under RIDDOR?
Not on its own. HSE’s RIDDOR guidance lists the collapse or overturning of lifting equipment, or the failure of a load-bearing part during normal operation, as dangerous occurrences. A defect found at examination without such an event is not on that list.
Re-Examination Or Renewal: Book A LOLER Inspection With GSB
We carry out LOLER thorough examinations and record every defect in the report against the item, with the remedy needed and, where a defect is not yet dangerous, the time by which it could become so. We examine and report only. We do not sell, hire, service or repair lifting equipment, so the defects we write up are not work we are hoping to win. Our five engineers cover anything from a single chain block to forklift trucks and other lifting equipment across several UK sites, with renewal dates kept in step.
If equipment has been repaired after a failed examination and you want it examined before it goes back into use, say so when you email the equipment list and site address to info@gsbinspections.co.uk, and we will tell you the earliest date we can offer. To talk a report through first, call 01782 855481; it goes to one of the two directors, both senior engineers, and we will still ask for the list in writing. We aim to come back with a quote within 48 hours. GSB Inspections is an associate member of SAFed.





