Who Can Carry Out A LOLER Thorough Examination?
A LOLER thorough examination has to be carried out by a competent person: someone with the practical and theoretical knowledge and experience of the lifting equipment to detect defects or weaknesses and judge how much they matter to its continued safe use. The law does not define the term or name a qualification. HSE’s guidance adds one more test that rules a lot of people out: the examiner must be sufficiently independent and impartial to make the call without fear or favour, which means the person who maintains the equipment should not normally be the one who examines it.
If you need lifting equipment examined, email the equipment list and site address to info@gsbinspections.co.uk and we aim to come back with a quote within 48 hours.
What LOLER Means By A Competent Person
Regulation 9 of the Lifting Operations and Lifting Equipment Regulations 1998 (LOLER) requires lifting equipment to be thoroughly examined for defects before first use (unless it is new and comes with a valid declaration of conformity), after installation or assembly at a new site where its safety depends on that, at regular intervals, and after exceptional circumstances. Each of those examinations must be made by a competent person.
“Competent person” is not defined in the regulations. HSE describes it in its guidance on thorough examination of lifting equipment: the examiner should have appropriate practical and theoretical knowledge and experience of the equipment, enough to detect defects or weaknesses and to assess their importance. The emphasis falls on the equipment being examined, so competence is judged item by item rather than in general.
Knowledge And Experience: What A LOLER Examiner Has To Judge
Spotting wear is the easy part. A thorough examination asks the examiner to decide whether that wear is a danger now, whether it will become one and by when, and what has to be done about it. Those judgements end up in the report, because Schedule 1 to LOLER requires every report to identify any defect that is or could become a danger, the repair, renewal or alteration needed, and, for a defect that is not yet dangerous, the time by which it could become so.
That is why a competent person for a set of chain slings is not automatically competent for a passenger lift or a mobile crane. The examiner needs to know the equipment type, how it fails, the standards it was built to, and how it is used on the site in front of them.
Independence: Why The Examiner Should Not Mark Their Own Work
HSE’s guidance says the competent person must be sufficiently independent and impartial to make their judgements without fear or favour, and that they should not be the same person who carries out routine maintenance on the equipment, because they would then be assessing their own maintenance work.
The same logic applies to firms. Many companies that examine lifting equipment also sell, hire, service or repair it, so the business writing up a defect may be the one paid to put it right. That does not make their examinations wrong, but it is a conflict worth weighing when you choose who examines your equipment.
Can Your Own Staff Carry Out LOLER Examinations?
Yes, in principle. HSE’s guidance accepts that the competent person may be employed by the same organisation as the equipment, provided they are sufficiently independent and impartial to make their judgements without fear or favour. In practice that means an in-house examiner who has the knowledge and experience for the specific equipment, who is not the person maintaining it, and whose findings are not overridden by production pressure.
In our experience, many employers find those conditions hard to meet with their own staff and use an outside inspection body instead.
Who Carries Out LOLER Thorough Examinations
Lifting equipment is generally examined by one of these:
- Engineering insurers’ surveyors, often arranged alongside the equipment’s insurance.
- Independent inspection bodies that examine and report without selling, hiring or servicing the equipment.
- Equipment suppliers, hire companies and service firms, which may examine the equipment they also maintain or supply.
- In-house competent persons, where the employer can meet the knowledge and independence tests above.
All four can be lawful. The questions below are the way to tell them apart.
What The Report Must Say About The Examiner
Schedule 1 to LOLER requires every report of thorough examination to give the name, address and qualifications of the person making the report, and whether they are self-employed or, if employed, the name and address of their employer. The report must also give the name and address of the person signing or authenticating it, and its date. If a report does not tell you who examined the equipment and on what basis, it is missing particulars the law requires.
Questions To Ask Before You Appoint A LOLER Examiner
- Who will carry out the examination, and on what basis are they a competent person for this equipment?
- Does the company also sell, hire, service or repair the equipment it is examining?
- Do they hold professional indemnity and public liability insurance?
- Will each report contain the full Schedule 1 particulars, including the latest date for the next examination?
- What exactly is included in the price, in writing?
Competent Person Questions
Is “competent person” defined in LOLER?
No. The term is not defined in the regulations. HSE’s guidance describes a competent person as someone with appropriate practical and theoretical knowledge and experience of the lifting equipment, enough to detect defects or weaknesses and assess their importance.
Does a LOLER examiner need a specific qualification?
The law does not name one. What it does require is that each report states the examiner’s qualifications, so you can see the basis on which they examined your equipment.
Can the company that services our equipment also examine it?
HSE’s guidance says the person who carries out routine maintenance should not normally be the one who examines the equipment, because they would be assessing their own work. Whether a firm can do both depends on how independent its examiners are from its maintenance work.
Can an employee carry out our LOLER examinations?
Yes, if they have the knowledge and experience for the equipment and are sufficiently independent and impartial to make their judgements without fear or favour.
Book A LOLER Inspection With GSB
We carry out LOLER inspections with engineers acting as competent persons, and every item gets a report of thorough examination with the Schedule 1 particulars. We examine and report only: we do not sell, hire, service or repair lifting equipment, so there is no repair work riding on what we find. With five engineers, we cover a single hoist as readily as multi-site contracts across the UK with renewal dates aligned.
Email the equipment list and site address to info@gsbinspections.co.uk, or call 01782 855481 to talk it through with one of the two directors, both senior engineers; we will still ask for the list in writing. We aim to come back with a quote within 48 hours. GSB Inspections is a SAFed associate member.





